Sip coffee guide

Iced coffee vs cold brew vs iced Americano

Same glass, same ice, three different ways of making the coffee.

Order any of these three black and you get a dark glass of coffee over ice. The difference is how the coffee was made, and that changes the taste more than you might expect.

How each one is made

Iced coffee

Coffee brewed hot, usually as drip or batch brew, then chilled and poured over ice. Many cafés brew it stronger than usual so the melting ice does not water it down, and some brew it straight onto ice (often called Japanese-style or flash-brewed iced coffee). It keeps more of the coffee's brightness and acidity.

Cold brew

Coarsely ground coffee steeped in cold or room-temperature water for 12 to 24 hours, then filtered. Without heat, less of the sharp acidity comes out, so cold brew tastes smooth and rounded, often with chocolatey notes. It is usually made as a strong concentrate and diluted before serving, and it tends to carry plenty of caffeine, though that depends on the recipe.

Iced Americano

Shots of espresso topped with cold water and poured over ice. It tastes like espresso, stretched out: bold, roasty and crisp, with a bitter edge. It is made to order, one glass at a time.

Side by side

DrinkMade withBrew timeTaste
Iced coffeeHot-brewed coffee, chilledMinutesBright, lighter, a little acidic
Cold brewCoffee steeped in cold water12 to 24 hoursSmooth, low in acidity, chocolatey
Iced AmericanoEspresso and cold waterUnder a minuteBold, roasty, crisp

All three come black. You can add milk, cream or syrup to any of them, and many cafés offer sweet cream or cold foam on cold brew (see cold brew vs nitro vs cold foam).

Which one should you order?

  • Bright and refreshing, like a classic cup of coffee: iced coffee.
  • Smooth, low in acidity, easy to drink black: cold brew.
  • Espresso flavor, bold and crisp: an iced Americano.
  • Sweet and creamy: none of them black. Add milk and syrup, or order an iced latte instead. See iced latte vs Spanish latte vs shaken espresso.
From the short

What Sip says for different tastes

Snap a café menu and Sip: What Coffee to Order ranks every drink on it for your taste, and says why. Sip reads all three as roasty and coffee-forward. The iced Americano is the most coffee-forward, cold brew is the roastiest, and cold brew is the only one it reads as chocolatey.

If you like it strong

  1. Iced Americano89
  2. Iced Coffee85
  3. Cold Brew80

Why Iced Americano: “Both coffee-forward and deep-roasted, which is where your taste sits.”

If you like it sweet & creamy

  1. Cold Brew60
  2. Iced Coffee58
  3. Iced Americano44

Why Cold Brew: “You lean deep-roasted, and this leads with it.” The catch: “It's coffee-forward, and your taste leans away from that.”

Scores are out of 100, printed by Sip's ranking engine for the example tastes in the short, with the reason it gives for its top pick. Your own scores come from a short taste quiz and the drinks you rate in your coffee diary, so they will differ.

Get Sip: What Coffee to Order

Photograph a café menu and Sip ranks every drink on it for your taste, and tells you why it picked each one. Rate what you ordered, and your coffee diary sharpens the next picks. Free, with an optional Sip Plus subscription.

More about Sip